Criticisms of the church abound and always will. With the recent election of a new Roman Pontifex Maximus and the passing of Western Easter, the media is ablaze with how the church in the 21st century deals with its relevancy, particularly to certain demographics like unmarried parishioners, children, gays, gun collectors, or any other group under the sun. I have written before that the church actually is at risk when it fractures its overall ministry into smaller ministries which have no connection to the whole. But, nonetheless, churches, particularly large evangelical megachurches, continue down this perilous self-destruction by its insistence on making a new ministry for every subgroup. And it doesn't stop at ministries. Now, there are worship services for married couples, childless couples, gay singles, straight singles, children, cat-people, dog-people (I exaggerate on the last two groups, but why not them?). If the Church is "catholic", i.e. encompassing the whole, then it must present itself as a "catholic" institution and not reinventing itself for every new trend or demographic out there.
Pastor Peters, a Lutheran, is definitely not a person who follows the current trends, but offers this explanation of what his church does offer for everyone. It is quite good. Other churches should take from this and apply it.
You can read the entire article here.
What does the Church have to offer children? Should we not cater to
them by including some children's music, a children's sermon, and some
simplified liturgy that is understandable to children? If we don't,
wouldn't we better serve children by dismissing them from the "adult"
nature of the Divine Service and sending them somewhere for content
designed for children in mind?
I have also had people say the same thing about disabled (both physical
and mental handicaps). What does the Church have to offer those who
physically cannot participate by speaking or singing or standing or
kneeling? I have heard people say the same thing about the single, the
single parent family, gay people, etc... What does the Church have to
offer people who are alone, unmarried, and without a family (implication
being that everything in worship is designed for the family)? What
does the Church have to offer those single parents who must wrestle with
their children alone and who often miss out on parts of worship because
they deal with restless or moody children (implication being that since
children don't get anything out of worship, at least the parent could
appreciate the service without the constraints of uncooperative children
to deal with)? What does the Church have to offer gay people
(implication being that the only thing the Church says to gays is that
they are unwelcome, evil, and corrupt)?
All of these questions begin with a false premise. We could spend a
great deal of time dealing with the straw men used to dismiss what the
Church has to offer folks who do not fit the prime mold of those who are
there on Sunday morning. But I will not do that. Instead, I will
offer a general response to the same question poised for different
people and different circumstances.
What does the Church have to offer?
- God's Word... the simplest answer. We offer the Word of God,
rightly preached, the Law and Gospel properly distinguished, speaking
the Word and applying the Word in the sermon, so that God may work as He
has willed and promised in the life of the person (no matter the age,
the maturity, the ability, or sexual orientation). The Word of God is a
means of grace. God is present in His Word and works through His
Word. This is not exclusively nor primarily understanding but the
communication of the Truth that endures forever, the Truth that is our
way, and the Truth that manifests God's presence and His gifts. Faith
is not an "aha" moment in which we finally "get it" but trust in the
will and works of God that give us life and salvation.
- The Sacraments of Life and Worship... We offer the means of grace,
the visible Word, through which God comes to us in the fullness of His
divine mercy to impart to us the grace that enables us to stand.
Through baptism we enter into the mystery of Christ's death and
resurrection, we are forgiven of our sins, we die and rise to new life
in Christ, and we exchange the old identity as no people for the new
identity as the people of God. Through the absolution we who continue
to sin find the power of grace both to call us to repentance and confess
our sin as well as to forgive that sin and restore us to our Lord.
Through the Eucharist we both become aware of our hunger and thirst and
our hunger and thirst are satisfied by the bread which is His body and
the cup of His blood, the intimate table fellowship that both unites us
to the God whose table it is and binds us as a people who confess a
common faith and live within its boundaries and discipline.
- Catechesis... We offer not only the directed catechesis of the
confirmation program (youth and adult) but the ongoing catechesis of the
liturgy and hymns of the Church. Faith is not something learned and
mastered as if one were learning a language but it is also a culture and
identity into which we are drawn and which we take on little by little
through the liturgy and hymns of the faith (as well as the Word and
Sacraments). Singing the faith is especially helpful for children and
those with limited intellectual ability but this is NOT the dumbing down
of the faith. Just the opposite. It is the life of the faithful in
which the faith is passed on by the form and words of the liturgy and
the words and music of the hymnody.
- Holy Life... We offer the vision of the holy life of faith. Here
the sanctoral cycle is especially helpful and it is a sad reality that
too many of our parishes and people have lost touch with this side of
the church's calendar. We learn from and grow into the holy life of the
faithful by knowing the stories of the faithful in whom and through
whom God has worked. They are not so much the objects of our attention
as the God who worked in them and through them. With this is our sense
of a chaste and pure life (no matter where we find ourselves -- married,
single, youth, aged, etc...). We do not mirror the values and goals of
the world around us but the holy life of our Lord Jesus Christ. This
is a goal of moral purity to be sure but it is surely more than that.
It is the life of self-denial in which we learn to love our neighbor as
Christ has loved us, where we learn to delight in the path of service,
and by which we learn what it means to be great in the Kingdom of God.
Holy living (perhaps we could call it sanctification but I am not sure
that word says much anymore) is not the domain of those who serve the
Church in churchly vocations but the path of life for all the
baptized.